ajsbear

Members
  • Content count

    825
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by ajsbear


  1. We have people in our area who refuse to acknowledge that we can be hit by coastal storms (nor'easter, tropical storm, or hurricane) so their planning for those is inadequate. Do you think they're really going to plan for a tsunami?

    We'd have better luck getting them to plan for Godzilla or the blob.

    You are right Chris but with the frequency of earthquakes the last few years, even in areas that do not get them as bad as they have been it can happen and the likelyhood keeps going up as more and more natural disaster occur.


  2. You are correct at 200 calls per year you can't justify career, but you also can't justify multiple fire stations, 3 engines, ladders, rescues, special teams, etc. And when you take out the automatic alarms and the minor calls you end up with 1 or 2 working fires per year, which is not enough to gain experience so as to be efficient and effective.

    Now whats interesting is other states and even other countries manage to cover these areas better than we do. Some with volunteers, some career and some combo. And they pay less in taxes, because they spread the burden out over a larger tax base.

    But this is not the case in Westchester.

    You are correct its economics, so tell me how do regional departments throughout the country manage to do it for less than here, with better responses, and with better insurance ratings, which saves the community 2 x 4 times what it costs to provide better fire protection?

    Last year I did a little research into what different departments spent on a per capita basis in Westchester and was very surprised to fine that the taxpayers in my city pay less per capita than those in about 1/2 the volunteer communities (and I stopped looking when I got to 1/2), and that includes paying for hydrants (and 30-40% less in insurance). How about this Yonkers with better staffing than NR spends less per capita and FDNY spends even less.

    Barry I agree with you. There is way too much equipment in Westchester and Putnam. More than anyplace else except maybe LI. Look at per square mile or by population. Each town, Look at all the departments in the town of Ossining, Greenburg, Cortlandt, North Castle or any of the other towns. Why does each department in a given town need a ladder and a rescue? At 1/2 million plus each why are we replacing many of them? I see a whole new argument starting.

    Dinosaur likes this

  3. This thread has become a sound off for Career vs Volunteer. Many communities just cannot afford a career department and the amount of runs just cannot justify the cost. A department with under 200 runs a year just cannot justify 50 career members plus officers. The further north you go into the rural areas the poorer some of hte departments are and some barely keep up with keeping equipment running, and have no where near the latest and greatest. A lot is a mater of economics. Yes if it was a perfect world, everyone would have the same training, same equipment etc. We all have to make due and the faster some people accept that the better. I for one do not want to pay any more taxes and have thought many times to pack it in and leave NY. Look at what the average home owner pays in taxes. Not just property but sales tax but every other little tax. Home heating oil. 3% more that Putnam just in a tax, the list goes on. So where does it end...Economics.

    SRS131EMTFF likes this

  4. It's tough to file a lawsuit with a company that has suddenly gone out of business..

    Tough buy not impossible. These people committed fraud. The changed the materials from the spec to a non spec material. While the company went belly up they may be able to hold the officers of the company liable.


  5. While the police get pressure from their bosses to get the roads open as fast as possible safety has to come first. One only has to look at pictures of the 3 rigs in Connecticut that were hit over the last few months on I 95. 3 rigs, at least 1.5 million dollars worth of rigs totaled. Still cheaper than a life. If the cop is creating an unsafe condition, pull all the men out, call for a Sgt. and wait. Firefighter safety comes first. Any of the state courses all say that.


  6. I think you're aware, civil service has come up with a way for people that do work like firefighting to prove they're competent to be promoted and lead. It's called the focused "competitive exam." Not having a college degree sometimes means people went straight into the workforce. Some of us were employed with civil service as young as 21. College didn't show me how to operate the pumps, the fire academy did. My officers showed me how to be one; and I tried my best to be as good as some of them were.

    The "inside joke" is one city fire chief.

    Would that be a current city chief how took classes in "how to be a chief in 3 easy lessens?"


  7. With the loss of an engine, what will happen to the department's ISO rating? Will insurance rates go up along with the taxes? If I owned a business in Newburgh, I'd sure be concerned....

    You can bet that insurance costs will go up once the insurance companies learn the ISO ratings will change and not for the better. As for neighboring VFD, I would respond when it is announced there is a life in danger. If it is a vacant, no. The brothers of NFD need to be reassured that everyone in the area has their backs. Once the life issue is dealt with, take a defensive posture band pack up. you don't need 200 guys to man a few deck guns. building and contents will suffer. In the areas where the buildings are close together, evacuate the entire city block for safety sake. Lost a block and lets see what the city council does.

    If the city going to do a recall of off duty personnel for major fires?

    Put Eng 3 back in service to cover the city?